A 2025 trial in Germany grew three CBD-rich cannabis lines in tunnels covered with plastic film. It compared two kinds of drip irrigation. In one, the drip line was buried in the soil (subsurface drip). In the other, the line lay on the soil surface (surface drip). The buried line used 18.6% less irrigation water, gave 5% more flower and raised CBD concentration by 9%. It also cut the dry weight of weeds by 93.2%.
The same trial tested fertilisers made from silver, copper and iron nanoparticles. They had no statistically significant effect on flower yield, CBD concentration, CBD yield or weed density. For growers in Thailand, the most useful results are the weed result and the nanoparticle result. You should not apply the water-saving figure to Thailand as a number.
Translator’s note on wording: in this article, “weeds” always means unwanted non-crop plants growing in the bed. It never means cannabis.
Who this applies to. In subsurface drip, the drip line sits under the soil. That means the method only works in in-ground beds or field production. In practice, that means mainly hemp and CBD fields, plus soil beds in greenhouses or tunnels. It does not apply to pots, grow bags or soilless media.
Translator’s note: if you grow in pots, grow bags or soilless media, only Section 4 (nanoparticle fertilisers) and Section 5 (how to judge a nano claim) apply to you.
1. The trial: who ran it, how, and what they found
Three researchers, C. Büser, J. Hartung and S. Graeff-Hönninger, ran the trial at a research station of the University of Hohenheim in Germany. They published the results in Journal of Cannabis Research in 2025.
How the trial was set up:
- Three foil tunnels. These are hoop-shaped tunnels covered with plastic film. Each tunnel was one replicate, meaning one complete run of the comparison. More replicates mean more confidence that a difference is real.
- Three genotypes (genetic lines), all chemotype III. In these plants CBD is the dominant cannabinoid.
- 72 plants per irrigation method in each tunnel.
- Planted on 15 July 2024. The trial covered one season.
- The buried line sat at 0.35 m (35 cm) depth.
- Nanoparticle fertilisers. In these products the nutrient element comes as particles measured in nanometres (billionths of a metre). Silver, copper and iron nanoparticles went in through the irrigation water every week. The trial tested them as a separate factor, alongside the irrigation comparison.
What they found:
| Measure | Subsurface vs surface drip |
|---|---|
| Irrigation water applied | 188.19 vs 231.23 L/m², 18.6% less |
| Largest gap (days 36–52 after planting) | 51% less |
| Dry weight of weeds (non-crop plants), measured on day 24 | 93.2% less |
| Inflorescence yield (weight of harvested flower clusters) | 5% more |
| CBD concentration | 9% higher |
| Silver / copper / iron nanoparticles | no significant effect on yield, CBD concentration, CBD yield or weed density |
The site’s climate was a mean annual temperature of 9.1 °C and average annual precipitation of 697 mm. These are long-term yearly averages for the site. They do not describe conditions inside the tunnels during the July–October growing season.
Translator’s note: many Thai growing sites run at 30–35 °C. That is far warmer than this German site. Treat the results as showing which way the effect goes, not as a forecast for your farm.
What to do: before you use any figure from the table, check that your crop grows in in-ground soil beds like the trial’s.
2. Why the water saving should not be quoted as a Thai figure
Subsurface drip saves water mainly by keeping the soil surface dry. A dry surface loses less water to evaporation. How much water you save depends on site, soil and season. Four things change it:
- Evaporative demand: how strongly heat, sun, wind and dry air pull water out of the soil and leaves.
- Soil texture: for example sandy or clay soil.
- Installation depth of the line.
- Crop stage.
The site’s yearly climate figures say little about this. The crop grew in summer under plastic film, so rain did not fall directly on the beds. The rainfall figure therefore does not affect the comparison.
The timing tells more. The gap between the two methods peaked at 51% between day 36 and day 52 after planting.
Translator’s note: the next point is an editorial reading, not a conclusion of the paper. The mid-season peak suggests the saving grows as evaporative demand rises. If that is correct, hot climates like Thailand’s could see larger savings, not smaller ones. However, no tropical data exist. So neither 18.6% nor 51% should be quoted as what Thai growers can expect. In this trial, the buried line clearly used less water than surface drip. You can only learn how big the saving is by measuring on your own site.
What to do: fit a water meter on each irrigation line and record litres per square metre every week (see Section 7). This gives you your own saving figure.
3. The 93% cut in weeds
Dry weight of weeds fell by 93.2%. The authors’ explanation is simple. Water released at 35 cm depth leaves the topsoil drier. Weed seeds in the top few centimetres get too little moisture to sprout.
The researchers weighed weeds only once, 24 days after planting. The figure therefore shows early-season control, not control over the whole season.
Translator’s note: why this may matter more in Thailand. Warmth and moisture last all year here. No cold season stops weed seeds in the soil from sprouting, so weeds keep coming year-round. Weeding inside a tunnel at 30–35 °C and high humidity is hard, slow work.
Translator’s note: two possible extra benefits (inferred, not measured). The study did not measure either of these. They follow from the drier soil surface:
- Less humid air at the base of the plants. This zone is where botrytis (grey mould) and soil-borne diseases start.
- Less soil splashing onto lower buds. Splashed soil carries microbes onto flower. This matters if your flower must pass a total yeast and mould limit, which is a lab count of yeast and mould. Flower above the limit fails testing.
Translator’s note: in the tropics, dry topsoil is not guaranteed. Some things keep the surface wet whatever irrigation method you use:
- Rainy-season rain on open fields.
- Condensation dripping from a tunnel roof.
- Moisture rising from wet soil further down.
When the surface stays wet, the weed control drops. A covered tunnel with its side walls managed (for example, closed during storms) may keep much of the benefit. An open field in the rainy season will keep much less. Nobody has tested this in Thailand.
What to do: after heavy rain, dig into the top 3–5 cm of a buried-drip bed with a finger or small trowel. Check again for the next few days. If the top layer stays moist for days, expect much weaker weed control than the trial reported.
4. Nanoparticle fertilisers: no measurable benefit
The paper found no statistically significant effect of silver, copper or iron nanoparticles on inflorescence yield, CBD concentration, CBD yield or weed density. “Statistically significant” means a difference too large to be explained by normal variation between plants and tunnels.
There was one narrow exception, involving irrigation water-use efficiency (how much crop each litre of water produced). In one genetic line only, out of the two analysed for this measure, the nanoparticle factor changed it. So saying the nanoparticles had “no effect on anything” would be wrong. But there was no main effect, meaning no effect averaged across all lines, on yield or quality.
The trial was a reasonable size. However, each tunnel counted as only one replicate. The authors report a loss of statistical power in some comparisons. Statistical power is a trial’s ability to detect a real but small difference. So this negative (null) result means no effect was detectable at this trial size. It does not prove the effect is zero.
Research on cannabis inputs rarely publishes negative results. That makes this one useful.
A separate 2026 review on silicon, published in Agriculture (MDPI), found that in direct comparisons, nano-silica was not consistently better than ordinary silicon sources (stabilised silicic acid or potassium silicate) at the same applied dose of silicon. That is a review finding, not a new trial. It does not repeat the cannabis result, but it agrees with it.
Translator’s note (an editorial view, not the paper’s conclusion): treat “nano” on a label as a sales word, not a growing claim. That changes only if a controlled trial shows the nano product beating the same element, at the same dose, in an ordinary form. Showing that evidence is the seller’s job, not the buyer’s. No such evidence for these products had been found when this article was prepared.
What to do: before you pay for a “nano” product, ask the seller the questions in Section 5.
5. How to judge a nano fertiliser claim
A fair test compares the nano product with the same element at the same dose in an ordinary form. A comparison with plants that got no fertiliser at all proves nothing about the nano form. It only shows that the element itself helps.
Ask the seller or distributor these questions:
- Which element does it supply, and how much per litre at the label rate? You need this to set up a fair comparison.
- Was it tested against the same element at the same dose in an ordinary form? If not, the trial cannot show that the nano form adds anything.
- How many plants and replicates were used, and was the difference statistically significant? A few plants in one room can show differences that happen by chance.
- Which crop and which climate? A result from another crop or a cool climate may not hold for cannabis at 30–35 °C.
If the seller can only show before-and-after photos, or a comparison with unfed plants, your question is still unanswered.
What to do: if you still want to try a nano product, split one small batch of plants. Give half the nano product. Give the other half an ordinary product that supplies the same amount of the same element. Keep water, light and everything else the same, and weigh the harvest from each half. This tells you whether the nano product does anything that the ordinary form does not.
6. What subsurface drip needs to work in Thailand
Roots growing into the drippers (emitters) and blocked emitters are the most common ways buried systems fail. You cannot see buried emitters. A blockage shows up as a struggling plant, not as a visible dry patch. That is why buried systems need a pressure gauge and a water meter on each line. If the flow drops or the pressure changes at the same pump setting, look for a blockage or a leak.
Water quality decides how long emitters last. Thai GACP (Good Agricultural and Collection Practice, the cultivation standard for medicinal plants) includes rules on irrigation water. For which water tests are required and how often, check the current cannabis GACP standard from the Department of Thai Traditional and Alternative Medicine (DTAM). No published province-level data on Thai irrigation water quality were found. Such data would include electrical conductivity (EC), which measures dissolved salts, or hardness (calcium and magnesium, which can form scale). Base your filter choice on a test of your own water.
Installation depth depends on your soil and on how deep and wide the roots spread. The trial’s 35 cm suited its soil. If the line is too deep, water drains below the roots and is wasted. If it is too shallow, the surface does not stay dry, and you lose the effect that cut weeds by 93%.
Translator’s note: power cuts and pump failure. In Thailand a power cut or a failed pump is a real risk. With surface drip you can see dry drippers. With a buried line you see nothing until plants wilt, and at 30–35 °C that can happen fast. Read the water meter after every irrigation cycle to confirm the water actually went in. Plan a backup, such as a generator or hand-watering. Hand-watering wets the surface for that day, but it keeps plants alive.
Translator’s note: buying the line. Some manufacturers make drip line designed for burial, with emitters protected against root intrusion. Ask official irrigation equipment distributors in Thailand whether their line is rated for burial and how its emitters are protected against roots. You can also ask for growers’ experience in the Outdoor Growing section of this forum.
Weigh the cost of converting your beds. The yield and CBD gains (5% and 9%) are modest. The stronger reason to switch is probably saved weeding labour, but no Thai cost data exist.
What to do: for one month, record the hours spent weeding each bed and what that labour costs. Compare that with the cost of converting the beds before you decide.
7. Where to start: one buried bed beside one surface bed
A small side-by-side trial on your own site answers the questions this German paper cannot. Run it only on a site that operates legally, and keep the records with your normal farm records.
- Pick two beds side by side, with the same soil, the same cultivar and the same planting date. This way, any difference comes from the irrigation method.
- Bury the line in one bed, at a depth suited to your soil (the trial used 35 cm). Lay the line on the surface in the other bed.
- Fit a water meter on each line. Each week, divide the litres used by the bed area to get litres per square metre. This gives you your own saving figure in place of 18.6%.
- On day 24, mark a square of the same size in each bed. Pull every weed inside it, sun-dry the weeds until brittle and weigh them. This lets you compare your result with the 93.2% at the same point the trial measured.
- Keep logging weeding hours for the whole season. The trial measured only day 24, and you need the full-season labour cost.
- After rain, and on mornings with roof condensation, check whether the top few centimetres are dry. This tells you whether the dry-surface effect holds on your site.
- At harvest, weigh the flower from each bed. If you test cannabinoids, compare CBD content too. This checks whether the 5% and 9% gains hold for you.
8. Limits of the evidence
- Three CBD lines, one site, one season, in Germany. No tropical repeat of the trial was found.
- Foil tunnel, not open field. In open fields during the rainy season, a wet surface (Section 3) adds a problem the trial did not face.
- Weeds were weighed only on day 24.
- No disease or microbe data. The extra benefits in Section 3 are inferred from how the method works, not measured.
- CBD-dominant lines, not THC-dominant ones. The 9% CBD gain is a chemotype III result.
- The 5% and 9% figures come from a single trial. Treat them as showing a direction, not a guaranteed size.
What to do: if you grow THC-dominant plants or grow in an open field, run the two-bed trial in Section 7 before you rely on any figure here.
9. What to take from this paper
- For in-ground growers, the main finding is weed control. It depends on a dry topsoil, so check your topsoil after rain and condensation.
- Do not quote 18.6% or 51% for Thailand. Measure your own saving with a water meter on each line.
- The nanoparticle fertilisers showed no detectable benefit in this trial. Ask sellers for a comparison with the same element at the same dose.
- The yield and CBD gains show a direction, not a guarantee. Compare the cost of converting with what you spend on weeding now.
If you run subsurface drip in Thailand, in a tunnel or in an open field, please post your results below this topic. The key question is whether the topsoil stayed dry enough through the rainy season to keep weeds down. Water meter readings and day-24 weed weights from side-by-side beds are especially useful. Only results from Thai sites can answer this question.
Further reading on the forum. The drip irrigation article linked in the introduction covers system design and maintenance. Other related topics:
- Outdoor Growing in Tropical Southeast Asian Climate
- Outdoor Cannabis in Southeast Asia: Seasons, Strains, and Pest Management Under Tropical Conditions
- Silicon for Cannabis: What the 2026 Review Supports, and the Four Claims It Rejects
- High Humidity Alone Cut CBD by 78% in a 2025 Controlled Trial
- What You May Legally Spray Under Thai GACP
This article is technical growing information for readers who operate legally where they live. Cannabis rules differ in every country. In Thailand, cannabis flower is a controlled herb under the Notification of the Ministry of Public Health Re: Controlled Herbs (Cannabis), B.E. 2568, in force since 26 June 2025. Selling, processing, research and export of flower require a licence. Flower may be sold only with a PT 33 prescription, and it may not be advertised in any channel or sold online. Nothing here is legal advice.
References
- Büser C, Hartung J, Graeff-Hönninger S. Subsurface drip irrigation reduces weed infestation and irrigation water use while increasing inflorescence and cannabinoid yield in an outdoor tunnel Cannabis sativa L. production system. Journal of Cannabis Research 7, 41 (2025)
- Integrating Silicon into Fertigation Strategies for Cannabis Production: A Comprehensive Review. Agriculture (MDPI), 2026, 16(14), 1522