Troubleshooting Living Soil: pH Lockout, Compaction, Climate Look-Alikes, a Diagnostic Checklist and Fungus Gnats (Part 2 of 2)

Source: adapted and edited from the book True Living Organics: The Ultimate Guide to Growing All-Natural Marijuana Indoors by The Rev (Green Candy Press, first published 2012; later editions have followed). The original is a printed book, so there is no link.

When a plant in living soil looks hungry, the soil is often not short of food. Living soil is a mix rich in compost and organic matter, where soil microbes break down dry amendments and feed the plant. In this kind of pot, a yellow or burnt leaf more often points to pH lockout, compacted soil without air, soil used before it was ready, or a room that is too hot, too dry or too bright. This part covers those causes, two things that look like damage but are not, a checklist to run before you change anything, and fungus gnats.

The Rev is the name the book’s author writes under. He grows indoors, and the thresholds and stories below come from his own garden. They are his view, not settled science. Where his claim differs from other sources, this article says so and gives the other view.

This is Part 2. Part 1: Troubleshooting Living Soil: Runoff Readings, Soil pH, Salt Build-Up and Acid Shock (Part 1 of 2)

Part 1 covered runoff readings, soil pH meters, salt build-up and acid shock (sections 1–4). The numbering continues here from section 5.

5. pH lockout: the usual causes in living soil

Lockout means a nutrient is present in the soil, but the plant cannot take it up. The usual reason is that pH sits outside the range where that nutrient stays available. General lockout is covered in Nutrient Lockout in Cannabis. In living soil, deficiency symptoms usually mean lockout, not a real shortage. The Rev lists these causes:

  • Too much molasses, or too much kelp or seaweed extract. Molasses is a sugar feed for soil microbes. He warns in particular that too much seaweed extract can block the uptake of other nutrients, nitrogen included.
  • Hard water with high PPM and high pH, from wells or the mains supply.
  • Pure water (RO water or rainwater) with an acidic liquid fertiliser added. Part 1, section 4, explains why this upsets the soil.
  • A minimalist setup: a large plant flowering in a small pot with no core feeding (dry amendments buried in holes in the pot). Here the soil really has run out. This one is real depletion, not lockout.

For the last case the fix is simple: a tea plus top-dressing. A tea is a liquid feed made by steeping compost or amendments in water. Top-dressing means spreading dry amendment or compost on the soil surface so it washes in with each watering. The Rev reports the plant greening up within 6–10 days.

Peat-heavy bagged soils. The Rev reports that mixes high in peat tended to drift down in pH when he recycled them. He suspects that fungi came to dominate the soil, and says he lost several crops before he stopped using them. He adds that peat is probably not a problem if you recycle plenty of plant material, kitchen waste and old root balls into the mix. This is one grower’s observation, not tested advice. It is plausible, though: peat is acidic, and fungi produce organic acids as they decompose material.

What to do: before you add any nutrient for a “deficiency”, measure soil pH in several places and list everything you added in the past month. If you recycle a peat-based mix, check its pH every cycle so a downward drift shows early.

6. Compacted soil, airless zones and uncured soil

These three problems are linked. Together they explain a large share of plants that decline for no obvious reason.

Compaction. Fresh coco coir and fine bark pieces give the mix structure. Over time they break down into finer particles and finally into humus (fully decomposed organic matter), so the soil gets denser. Dense soil runs out of air. It becomes anaerobic, meaning without oxygen, and roots die. The Rev’s rule is perlite at 20–25% of the pot volume. Perlite and other aeration amendments have their own article on the forum.

A habit that compacts soil: lifting the pot to judge how dry it is, then setting it down hard. The Rev notes this can compact a pot noticeably within a month. Lift it gently and set it down gently.

Uncured soil. Curing means letting a freshly amended mix sit moist so microbes can break the amendments down before you plant. A batch used too early produces stunted plants and can kill them outright, usually through airless conditions in the pot. The good news is that fully cured soil stores well. In The Rev’s view, nutrients do not evaporate and over-curing does no harm. If in doubt, cure longer. Use the soil pH test from Part 1, section 2, instead of guessing: the pH rises as a batch finishes curing, and The Rev uses batches that read 6.2 or above.

Translator’s note: in the rainy season pots dry slowly, so soil without enough air stays wet longer and roots suffocate sooner. Store cured soil covered and off the ground, so rain cannot soak it.

What to do: when you recycle soil, add perlite by volume. One bucket of perlite to three or four buckets of mix gives 20–25%. Write the ratio on the batch label so you know what each pot contains.

7. Climate problems that look like nutrient problems

Growers often mistake these for feeding errors:

Cause What it looks like Fix
Light too close or too strong Dry, brittle leaf tips or bleached leaves at the top of the canopy. With HID lamps (high-intensity discharge lamps such as high-pressure sodium and metal halide), heat at the canopy as well; The Rev caps canopy temperature at 30 °C Raise or dim the light. With LED, follow the maker’s hanging height and PPFD guidance (PPFD is the amount of light reaching the leaves). Topic 1001 covers grow lights
Hot, dry air Scorched leaf edges and burnt tips that look like potassium deficiency Raise relative humidity (RH) toward 50–60%, or lower the temperature. Do not point strong, dry airflow straight at the leaves. Make sure the soil holds enough potassium (kelp, greensand, balanced dry amendments)
Cold temperature while the lights are off Slower uptake of potassium and phosphorus; purple streaks on stems Raise the lights-off temperature. This is rare in this region, except in rooms with strong air conditioning at night, or highland grows in the cool season

Why hot, dry air looks like potassium deficiency. Plants do not “sweat out” potassium. Hot air with low RH gives a high vapour pressure deficit (VPD), the drying pull the air puts on the leaf. The plant then transpires, or gives off water through its leaves, much faster. Water uptake can outrun nutrient supply. Dissolved salts concentrate at the leaf edges and in the root zone. At the same time the plant needs more potassium, because potassium drives the stomata, the leaf pores that open and close all day. The result is damage that looks like potassium deficiency, and a real potassium shortfall if the soil cannot keep up. Ventilation itself is not the problem. Very dry air moving fast across the leaves raises transpiration further.

This row matters most in this region, because air conditioning removes moisture fast. A room cooled to a comfortable temperature can easily sit below 45% RH. It then produces potassium-type symptoms that look like a soil problem.

Translator’s note: in a Thai room at 30–35 °C, keeping the canopy at or below The Rev’s 30 °C cap usually needs air conditioning, and air conditioning is what dries the air. Measure both numbers before you decide whether the soil is at fault.

What to do: hang a thermometer-hygrometer at the top of the canopy, not on the wall. Log temperature and RH morning and evening for one week before you change anything in the soil.

8. Two things that look like damage but are not problems

Lower leaves yellowing in late flower. The plant is moving nitrogen out of its least productive leaves toward the top of the plant, which is normal. Let it happen. Remove the leaves only once they are dry and brittle (Pruning the TLO Way explains why), and recycle them into your soil. If the yellowing spreads unusually fast, suspect overwatering before deficiency.

Root damage after transplanting. The signs are burnt leaf edges curling upward at the top of the plant, and a generally lifeless look. The Rev’s advice is firm: do nothing. Give no vitamin B and no additives, which in his view only unbalance the soil. Give plain water at sensible intervals and keep stress low. He expects full recovery in around 10 days. Topic 1341 covers transplanting in more detail.

What to do: after a transplant, write the date on the pot and wait 10 days before you decide anything is wrong. In late flower, check how wet the pot is before you blame a lack of food for yellow leaves.

9. The diagnostic checklist

When several plants are struggling and you cannot find a cause, The Rev suggests asking yourself these questions. The reason for each is in brackets.

  1. When did I last change the carbon filter on my water supply? (A worn-out carbon filter lets chlorine through to the soil microbes.)
  2. How old is my RO membrane, and have I checked the water’s PPM recently? (An old membrane lets more dissolved minerals through.)
  3. Has anything changed in my lighting: hanging height, dimmer setting or, for HID lamps, bulb age? (Light changes show up as leaf damage at the top of the canopy.)
  4. Is anything wrong with my ventilation? (Poor airflow changes temperature and humidity at the leaves.)
  5. Have I been lazy about topping up perlite when recycling soil? (Too little perlite leads to compaction and airless soil, section 6.)
  6. Have I checked for light leaks: vent tape, tent seam tape, the light-block flap behind the door zip? (Light during the dark period stresses flowering plants.)
  7. Have I changed any ratios, or tried new products or brands, in the past few months? (One new liquid feed can cause acid shock, Part 1 section 4.)
  8. Have I checked the timer settings? (A wrong timer changes the light hours.)
  9. How sure am I that my meters are accurate? (A wrong meter sends you after a problem that does not exist.)
  10. How old is my mycorrhizal inoculant? (Old inoculant may no longer contain living fungi.)
  11. Were my genetics bred under mineral nutrients? (A line selected on bottled nutrients may not do as well in living soil.)

The main rule: change one thing at a time, then wait and watch. The Rev suggests one to two months. If the decline is fast, look at what you did about two weeks ago. If it is slow, look at the past two months.

On hermaphrodites (plants that grow both female and male flowers, see topic 290): The Rev’s view is that a plant turning hermaphrodite is more often the grower’s error than the genetics, unless the line’s origin is unknown. In his own garden the usual cause was light leaks. That is his experience, not a rule, but checking seals regularly costs nothing. Tent vent tape wears out, and tents flex as the ventilation cycles on and off.

What to do: print the checklist and go through it in writing before you change anything. Once a month during the dark period, stand inside the closed tent with the room light on outside, and look for pinholes of light at seams, vents and the door.

10. Fungus gnats: tolerable in small numbers, not harmless

Fungus gnats are small dark flies whose larvae live in moist soil. The Rev takes the unusual position that they are hard to avoid in living soil and do little harm in small numbers. His reasoning is that the larvae help break down organic matter. Other sources only partly agree.

The documented risks:

  • Larvae feed on roots and tunnel into stems at the soil line. Agricultural extension services (the farm advisory services run by universities and governments) describe them as especially destructive to seedlings, clones and young plants. Mature plants also suffer when numbers are high.
  • Larvae can carry root-rot organisms, including Pythium and Fusarium. The wounds they make while feeding also let other soil-borne diseases into the roots.

In a humid tropical room, gnat numbers never get a natural break. This is especially true of a perpetual-harvest room, where new plants go in as others come out and the room is never empty. That risk is real.

Monitoring and control:

  • Place yellow sticky traps just above the soil surface, and count the adult gnats each week.
  • If the numbers climb, drench the soil with Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. israelensis (Bti). This is the strain of the bacterium that targets gnat larvae; other Bt strains do not.
  • Protect seedlings and clones first.

Decide by the trap counts and by how young your plants are, not by a general rule.

Translator’s note: in Thailand, use only pest-control products registered with the Department of Agriculture (กรมวิชาการเกษตร), and follow the label. Ask the seller for the registration number before you buy a Bti product. Gnats breed in a constantly wet top layer of soil, so letting the surface dry between waterings also helps.

What to do: set two sticky traps per tent and write the weekly count in your grow log. A rising count is your signal to act, before larvae reach the roots of your youngest plants.


Which of these problems did you diagnose correctly the first time? Post your case below this topic: what you saw, what you measured and what fixed it. Salt build-up from unwashed local coir may be under-diagnosed in this region. If you have measured the EC of your coir before and after rinsing, please share the numbers here too.

This article is educational horticultural information only. In Thailand, cannabis flower is a controlled herb under the Notification of the Ministry of Public Health Re: Controlled Herbs (Cannabis), B.E. 2568, in force since 26 June 2025. Cultivation must be licensed, and any flower sold or exported must come from a GACP-certified cultivation site. Flower may be sold only against a PT 33 (ภ.ท.33) prescription, for at most 30 days. Advertising flower and selling it online are prohibited, and recreational use is not permitted. The draft Cannabis Control Act is not yet law: the Cabinet approved the draft on 22 September 2026 and sent it to the House. Check the law where you live; nothing here is legal advice.


Further reading on Asiannabis