An out-of-specification (OOS) result is any test result that falls outside the specification or acceptance criteria set for a product. Under GMP, every OOS result must be investigated to find its cause; it cannot simply be replaced by a new test.
What the guidance says
The US Food and Drug Administration’s guidance on OOS results (revised 2022) covers all results outside the limits set by the manufacturer, the product file or the official pharmacopoeia. It sets out two phases:
- Phase I, laboratory investigation. Was it a lab error, for example an instrument fault or a dilution mistake? Retesting may be part of this phase, using the same homogeneous sample, often by a second, equally qualified analyst.
- Phase II, full-scale investigation. If no lab error is found, the investigation moves to production: the batch, the process and other batches that may be affected.
The international GMP guideline for active ingredients, ICH Q7, also asks that any OOS result be investigated and documented by a written procedure. It adds that OOS batches must not be blended with other batches to meet the specification.
“Testing into compliance”
The FDA guidance names a practice it calls objectionable: testing again and again until a passing result appears, then ignoring the failed results without scientific reason. It also warns about averages. If some results in a series fail and others pass, the passing ones are no more likely to be true. The average should be treated as OOS, even when it falls within the limit.
In Thailand and Southeast Asia
An export buyer working under GMP may ask how you handle a failed test. Sending new samples to new labs until one passes, and discarding the rest, is the practice the FDA calls testing into compliance. Keep every result, including the failures.
Common mistakes
- Deleting or hiding the first result. All results stay on file.
- Blending a failed batch with a good one. This is not allowed under ICH Q7.
- Retesting without a written plan. Decide in advance how many retests are allowed and who does them.
Write a one-page OOS procedure now: who is told, what is checked first, and how many retests are allowed, and follow it the next time a test fails.
Related terms
Deviations and CAPA · Remediation · Action Limit · Data Integrity (ALCOA) · Quality Control (QC) · Batch Record · COA (Certificate of Analysis)