What Are Open and Closed Systems? Whether Drain Water Is Discarded or Reused

Open and closed systems are the two options for what happens to drain water in soilless growing. In an open system, the drain water is discarded after each irrigation. In a closed system, it is collected, topped up with water and nutrients, and fed to the plants again.

How they differ

An FAO guide to greenhouse soilless culture sets out the trade-off. In an open system, growers supply more solution than the plants need. Every plant then gets enough, and salts such as sodium do not build up around the roots. The surplus leaves as drain, and the guide notes that it is often lost to the environment.

In a closed system, the drain is recovered, replenished and recycled. This saves water and fertiliser. The guide names two limits:

  • Salt build-up. Ions that enter with the source water faster than plants take them up, such as sodium, collect in the recycled solution. Good-quality source water is the main defence.
  • Disease spread. Recycled drain can carry root pathogens from plant to plant, so a closed system needs a disinfection step.

Some systems are closed by design. In nutrient film technique (NFT) channels, the solution drains to a pipe that returns it to the tank. Slabs and pots fed by drippers can run either way.

How it relates to run-to-waste

Run-to-waste is the everyday name for an open drip system. The run-to-waste page covers how to keep it efficient. This page compares it with the closed alternative.

Common mistakes

  • Recycling drain without testing the source water. Sodium-rich water makes a closed system hard to run, because the sodium keeps returning and building up.
  • Topping up by EC alone. EC shows total salts, not which ones. The FAO guide recommends analysing the solution in rockwool slabs at least once a month.
  • Pouring open-system drain into ditches or canals. It carries fertiliser into waterways. Collect it and dispose of it responsibly.

Before you choose between open and closed, have a lab test your source water for sodium and EC.

Related terms

run-to-waste · runoff · nutrient-film-technique · deep-water-culture · ec · root-rot · Hanging Gutter

Read more on Asiannabis

References